LeanRoot Cause Analysis

The $20 Fan That Didn’t Solve the Problem

Avatar photo By Ron Pereira Updated on November 18th, 2026

There’s an old manufacturing story, often called the toothpaste box story, that’s been circulating for at least 20 years. You may have heard it. It involves a toothpaste factory, an elaborate engineering solution, and a $20 desk fan.

It goes something like this.

A toothpaste manufacturer was dealing with a serious problem. Empty toothpaste boxes were making their way through the manufacturing and packaging process and eventually reaching customers.

Management decided something needed to be done.

So they brought in engineers who spent months developing a sophisticated system to detect the empty boxes. The solution involved precision scales, sensors, and equipment that would stop the production line whenever an empty box was detected.

According to legend, the system cost around $8 million.

And it worked.

Whenever an empty box came down the line, the system detected it and stopped production so someone could remove the empty box.

Problem solved, right? Well, not exactly.

You see, a few months after this system was installed the leadership team noticed the line rarely ever stopped. As such, they wondered if the production process had somehow improved?

Not quite.

It turns out the line operator was sick and tired of the line constantly stopping so she could remove the empty boxes. So she came up with her own solution.

She placed a $20 desk fan beside the conveyor belt. The fan was powerful enough to blow the empty boxes off the line while allowing the heavier, properly filled boxes to continue on down the line.

No expensive sensors. No complicated engineering. No more stopping the line.

Just a fan.

The Hero of the Story

If you’ve heard this story before, you probably know how it ends.

The $20 fan is celebrated as an example of brilliant simplicity. The employee becomes the hero who solved a multi-million dollar problem with a little creativity and common sense.

And to be fair, I think the operator definitely deserves some recognition.

She saw an opportunity to improve the process and took action. She also eliminated unnecessary downtime and found an inexpensive way to accomplish what the sophisticated system was designed to do.

That’s good improvement thinking.

But there’s something about this story that’s always bothered me.

The factory is still producing empty toothpaste boxes.

Think about that for a moment.

The engineers developed an expensive way to detect empty boxes.

The line operator developed an inexpensive way to remove empty boxes.

But neither solution, at least as the story is told, addressed why the boxes were empty in the first place.

A Better Countermeasure Isn’t Necessarily a Solution

This is where I think the story gets really interesting.

In continuous improvement, we often celebrate clever countermeasures. And we should. Finding a simpler, faster, or less expensive way to deal with a problem can create tremendous value.

But we also need to distinguish between containing a problem and preventing it from happening.

The sophisticated system was a form of defect detection. It identified empty boxes and prevented them from moving further through the process.

The fan accomplished essentially the same thing, only with less complexity and fewer interruptions.

Both approaches addressed the consequences of the problem.

Neither, at least as described in the story, got to the root cause of the actual problem.

Was there an issue with how toothpaste tubes were being fed into the packaging equipment? Was a sensor malfunctioning? Was there a timing problem between machines? Was something else happening upstream?

We don’t know.

And that’s precisely what’s missing from the story.

Don’t Stop at the Fan

Now, please don’t take this the wrong way. I don’t want to suggest that the fan was a bad idea.

Quite the opposite.

Sometimes we need immediate countermeasures to protect customers, maintain production, or reduce waste while we investigate a deeper problem.

There’s nothing wrong with that…especially when the countermeasure is inexpensive and easy to implement.

In fact, a good containment measure can give a team the breathing room it needs to investigate the root cause without constantly fighting fires.

But that only works if we actually continue the investigation.

Imagine if the toothpaste factory celebrated the employee, documented the savings, and then moved on to the next improvement project.

The fan might keep running for years.

And empty boxes might keep coming down the conveyor belt for years.

The company would have improved how it handles defects without improving the process that creates them.

That’s a missed opportunity.

What Are We Blowing Off the Conveyor Belt?

I suspect most organizations have their own versions of the $20 fan.

Maybe it’s a spreadsheet someone created to reconcile information between two systems.

Maybe it’s an extra inspection step that catches mistakes before products reach customers.

Or perhaps it’s a person who has become exceptionally good at fixing the same problem day after day.

These countermeasures can be valuable. Some may even be necessary.

But they can also become so familiar and effective that we stop questioning why they’re needed.

And that’s where we need to be careful.

Because the absence of visible defects doesn’t necessarily mean the process is capable of producing defect-free results.

Sometimes it just means we’ve gotten really good at catching the defects.

One More Question

I still like the toothpaste box fan story. Actually, I love it if I’m being totally honest.

I appreciate the creativity and simplicity. And I especially like that someone close to the work recognized an opportunity that others had overlooked.

Those are lessons worth celebrating.

But I think the story deserves one more chapter.

After installing the fan, what did the team do to figure out why the boxes were empty?

Did they study the packaging process? Did they identify the root cause? Did they make changes that prevented the defect from occurring?

Or did everyone simply celebrate the fan and move on?

We may never know. After all, this is a widely circulated manufacturing parable, not a verified case study.

But the question is worth asking in our own organizations.

Are we solving problems, or are we just getting better at dealing with them?

Sometimes a $20 fan is a great improvement.

Just don’t let it be the end of the story.


Have something to say?

Leave your comment and let's talk!

Start your improvement training today.